Skip to content

Tips for Discovering Underrated Cards

Tips for Discovering Underrated Cards in mtg

In the world of Magic: The Gathering, there’s a hidden treasure trove of potential waiting to be discovered: underrated cards. These are the cards that, for one reason or another, don’t get the attention they deserve. Discovering Underrated Cards might be overshadowed by more popular cards, or perhaps their potential isn’t immediately obvious. But with a keen eye and a strategic mind, these underrated cards can become powerful tools in your MTG arsenal.

Key Takeaways: Underrated Cards

  • Understanding the concept of underrated cards can enhance your gameplay.
  • Discovering underrated cards involves research, experimentation, and a keen eye for potential.
  • Historical and recent examples of underrated cards show their potential to become game changers.
  • Strategies for incorporating underrated cards into your deck can help balance your gameplay.
  • Mastering the element of surprise and adapting your playstyle are key to maximizing the strengths of underrated cards.

Understanding the Concept of Discovering Underrated Cards

Discovering Underrated Cards

When we talk about underrated cards, we’re referring to those cards that are often overlooked or undervalued by the majority of players. These cards might not be the flashiest or the most powerful on their own, but in the right context, they can be game-changers.

For example, consider a card like Tetsuko Umezawa, Fugitive. At first glance, this card might not seem like much. It’s a 1/3 creature for two mana, and its ability only affects creatures with power or toughness 1. But in a deck built around small, evasive creatures, Tetsuko can be a powerhouse, making all your creatures unblockable and swinging games in your favor.

Why Focusing on Discovering Underrated Cards Can Improve Your Game

Focusing on underrated cards can significantly improve your game in several ways. First, it can give you an edge over your opponents. When you’re using cards that aren’t commonly played, your opponents are less likely to be prepared for them, giving you an element of surprise.

Second, underrated cards often have unique or niche effects that can catch opponents off guard. This unpredictability can be a significant advantage in a game as complex and strategic as Magic: The Gathering.

Finally, building decks around underrated cards can be a fun and rewarding challenge. It encourages you to think outside the box and explore new strategies, which can make you a better player in the long run.

So, whether you’re a seasoned veteran or a newcomer to the game, don’t overlook the potential of underrated cards. They might just be the secret weapon you need to take your game to the next level.

The Art of Discovering Underrated Cards

Finding underrated cards in Magic: The Gathering is like unearthing hidden gems. It requires a keen eye, a deep understanding of the game, and a willingness to experiment. But don’t worry, it’s not as daunting as it might sound. With a few tips and tricks, you’ll be discovering underrated cards in no time.

Recognizing the Potential in Less Popular Cards

The first step in discovering underrated cards is learning to recognize potential where others might not. This means looking beyond a card’s surface-level attributes and considering how it might fit into a broader strategy.

One with Nothing

For instance, a card might have a seemingly weak effect or a high mana cost that makes it unpopular among most players. But in the right deck or under the right circumstances, that same card could become a powerful asset.

Take One with Nothing for example. This card has been widely regarded as one of the worst cards in MTG history. After all, who would want to discard their entire hand? But in a deck built around the Hellbent mechanic or Madness cards, One with Nothing can be a game-changer.

Using Online Resources and Communities to Identify Underrated Cards

Another great way to discover underrated cards is by tapping into the collective wisdom of the MTG community. There are countless forums, blogs, and social media groups dedicated to discussing Magic: The Gathering, and these can be a goldmine of information.

Sites like MTG Salvation and Reddit’s r/magicTCG are full of players sharing their deck ideas and card recommendations. You can also check out Scryfall, a comprehensive MTG card search engine, to explore cards based on specific criteria.

Remember, the key to discovering underrated cards is to keep an open mind and be willing to experiment. Not every card you try will be a hit, but the process of testing and refining your deck is part of what makes Magic: The Gathering such a rewarding game. So go ahead, dig into those lesser-known cards, and you might just find your new secret weapon.

Case Studies of Underrated Cards

One of the best ways to understand the power of underrated cards is to look at examples from the past and present. These case studies highlight how overlooked cards can rise to prominence and influence the game in unexpected ways.


Historical Examples of Underrated Cards that Became Game Changers

Let’s take a trip down memory lane and look at some underrated cards from Magic’s past that ended up making a big impact.

First up is Necropotence. When it was first released in the Ice Age set, many players dismissed it due to its life payment mechanic. However, it didn’t take long for players to realize that the card advantage it provided was well worth the life cost. Necropotence quickly became a cornerstone of the infamous “Black Summer” meta and is now considered one of the most powerful cards in the game.

Another example is Skullclamp. This card was initially overlooked due to its seemingly weak effect. However, players soon discovered that it could be used to turn small creatures into card draw engines, leading to its eventual banning in several formats.

Recent Underrated Cards Making Waves in the MTG Arena


Now, let’s turn our attention to the digital realm of MTG Arena. Here are a couple of recent underrated cards that have been making waves.

Roiling Regrowth

Roiling Regrowth is a card that initially flew under the radar. It’s a simple land search card, but its ability to trigger landfall twice in a single turn has made it a staple in many landfall decks.

Another card that has been gaining popularity is Selfless Savior. This one-drop creature might not look like much, but its ability to protect a more valuable creature from destruction has made it a favorite among many players.

These case studies show that underrated cards can come from anywhere, whether it’s an old set or the latest release. So keep an eye out, and don’t be afraid to give those overlooked cards a second look. They might just surprise you.

Strategies for Incorporating Underrated Cards into Your Deck

Now that we’ve explored the concept of underrated cards and looked at some examples, let’s dive into the practical side of things. How do you incorporate these hidden gems into your deck? Here are some strategies to help you make the most of underrated cards.

Balancing Your Deck with a Mix of Popular and Underrated Cards

One of the keys to using underrated cards effectively is balance. While it can be tempting to fill your deck with as many hidden gems as you can find, it’s important to remember that popular cards are popular for a reason. They’re reliable, powerful, and often offer great value for their cost.

A well-balanced deck will include a mix of popular cards for their proven power and underrated cards for their potential and surprise factor. This approach gives you the best of both worlds, allowing you to leverage the strengths of both types of cards.

Discovering Underrated Cards

For example, in a Commander deck, you might choose a popular commander like Atraxa, Praetors’ Voice for her powerful abilities. But then, you could fill your deck with underrated cards that synergize with Atraxa’s abilities, catching your opponents off guard and giving you an edge.

Experimenting with Different Deck Builds to Maximize the Potential of Underrated Cards

Another important strategy for using underrated cards is experimentation. Don’t be afraid to try out different deck builds and strategies to see what works best. Remember, the true value of an underrated card often lies in how well it synergizes with the rest of your deck.

For instance, you might try building a deck around an underrated commander like Tetsuo Umezawa. While Tetsuo might not be as immediately powerful as some other commanders, his ability to destroy target creatures can be devastating in the right deck.

Tetsuo Umezawa

The key is to keep an open mind and be willing to experiment. You never know when you might stumble upon a powerful new strategy or discover a hidden gem of a card. So go ahead, start exploring the world of underrated cards, and see where it takes you.

The Role of Meta in Identifying Underrated Cards

In the world of Magic: The Gathering, the “meta” refers to the current state of the game. It’s a snapshot of the most popular decks, strategies, and cards at any given time. Understanding the meta is crucial for any player, but it’s especially important when it comes to identifying underrated cards.

Understanding the Current Meta and Its Impact on Card Ratings

The meta can have a significant impact on how cards are rated and perceived by players. Cards that are effective against popular decks or strategies will often be rated highly, while those that don’t fit into the current meta might be overlooked.

For example, if the meta is dominated by creature-heavy decks, then cards that can deal with multiple creatures at once, like Wrath of God, will be highly valued. On the other hand, a card like Duress, which is excellent against control decks, might be underrated if there aren’t many control decks in the meta.

How to Use Meta Shifts to Discover New Underrated Cards

One of the most exciting aspects of Magic: The Gathering is that the meta is always changing. New sets are released regularly, introducing new cards and mechanics that can shake up the game. These shifts in the meta can create opportunities to discover new underrated cards.

When a new set is released, take some time to look through the new cards and think about how they might fit into the current meta. Are there any cards that could counter the popular strategies? Or perhaps there are cards that synergize well with existing underrated cards?

Remember, the meta is just one factor to consider when identifying underrated cards. A card’s potential isn’t solely determined by its effectiveness in the current meta. With a bit of creativity and strategic thinking, you can find underrated cards that will give you an edge in any meta. So keep exploring, keep experimenting, and most importantly, have fun!

Tips for Playing with Underrated Cards

Playing with underrated cards can be a thrilling experience. The element of surprise, the joy of discovery, and the satisfaction of pulling off a strategy that no one saw coming – it’s all part of the fun. But how do you make the most of these hidden gems? Here are some tips to help you master the art of playing with underrated cards.

Mastering the Element of Surprise with Underrated Cards

Shirei, Shizo's Caretaker

One of the biggest advantages of playing with underrated cards is the element of surprise. When you play a card that your opponent isn’t expecting, it can throw off their game plan and give you an edge.

For example, imagine you’re playing a deck built around the underrated commander Shirei, Shizo’s Caretaker. Your opponent might not be prepared for the constant stream of creatures returning from your graveyard, giving you an advantage.

To maximize the element of surprise, try to keep your underrated cards hidden until the perfect moment. This might mean holding back a card in your hand until it can have the most impact, or waiting to play a card from your graveyard until your opponent least expects it.

Adapting Your Playstyle to Maximize the Strengths of Underrated Cards

Underrated cards often require a different playstyle to maximize their potential. This might mean building your deck around a specific card or mechanic, or adapting your strategy to take advantage of an underrated card’s unique abilities.

For instance, if you’re playing with Zada, Hedron Grinder, you’ll want to include plenty of cheap instant and sorcery spells in your deck. Each time you target Zada with a spell, it copies for each other creature you control, turning a simple spell into a powerful game-changing effect.

Remember, the key to playing with underrated cards is flexibility and creativity. Don’t be afraid to try new strategies, experiment with different deck builds, and think outside the box. With a bit of practice and a lot of fun, you’ll be mastering the art of playing with underrated cards in no time.

Conclusion: The Hidden Power of Underrated Cards

We’ve journeyed through the world of underrated cards, exploring their potential, learning how to identify them, and discovering strategies to incorporate them into our decks. It’s clear that these hidden gems can offer a unique and rewarding experience for any Magic: The Gathering player.

Recap of the Importance and Benefits of Discovering and Using Underrated Cards

Underrated cards are more than just overlooked pieces of cardboard. They’re opportunities for creativity, innovation, and surprise. They challenge us to think outside the box, to question the status quo, and to find value where others might not.

Whether it’s the thrill of catching your opponent off guard with an unexpected card, the satisfaction of discovering a powerful synergy that no one else has noticed, or the joy of seeing an underrated card rise to become a game-changer, there’s something truly special about these hidden gems.

Encouragement for Continued Exploration of Underrated Cards in MTG and MTG Arena

So keep exploring, keep experimenting, and keep challenging the meta. Remember, every card in Magic: The Gathering has potential. It’s up to you to uncover it.

Whether you’re a seasoned veteran or a newcomer to the game, I encourage you to delve into the world of underrated cards. You might be surprised by what you find. After all, in the words of the great planeswalker Jace Beleren, “There’s always more to learn.” So let’s keep learning, keep playing, and most importantly, keep having fun with Magic: The Gathering.

Related Reading and References

The journey to discovering and mastering the use of underrated cards in Magic: The Gathering doesn’t end here. There’s a wealth of resources out there to help you continue your exploration. Here are some suggested blogs, articles, and resources that can provide further reading on the topic.

Suggested Blogs, Articles, and Resources for Further Reading on Underrated Cards

  1. MTG Goldfish: This site offers a wealth of information on all things Magic, including deck lists, strategy guides, and articles on underrated cards.
  2. Channel Fireball: Another great resource for Magic players, Channel Fireball offers articles, videos, and guides from some of the game’s top players.
  3. Reddit’s r/magicTCG: This subreddit is a great place to discuss Magic: The Gathering with other players. You’ll often find discussions about underrated cards and unique deck strategies.
  4. Tolarian Community College on YouTube: This YouTube channel offers a variety of Magic content, including deck techs, product reviews, and discussions about underrated cards.
  5. EDHREC: If you’re a Commander player, EDHREC is an invaluable resource. It offers a wealth of data on popular commanders and cards, as well as articles and podcasts.

References Used in the Creation of This Blog Post

  1. Gatherer: The official Magic: The Gathering card database. Used for card references throughout this post.
  2. Scryfall: A comprehensive Magic: The Gathering card search engine. Used for card references and research.
  3. MTG Wiki: A community-driven Magic: The Gathering encyclopedia. Used for historical information and card references.

Remember, the world of Magic: The Gathering is vast and ever-changing. There’s always more to learn, more to discover, and more underrated cards to uncover. So keep exploring, keep learning, and most importantly, keep having fun. Happy gaming!


As we wrap up our exploration of underrated cards in Magic: The Gathering, let’s address some common questions that players often have about this topic. These FAQs should provide you with some quick insights and tips for further exploration into the world of underrated cards.

What makes a card underrated in Magic: The Gathering?

A card is considered underrated when it’s not commonly used or recognized by the majority of players, despite having potential or unique abilities that can be powerful in the right circumstances. These cards often require a bit more creativity or strategic thinking to use effectively, but they can offer a unique edge in gameplay.

How do I identify underrated cards?

Identifying underrated cards involves a mix of research, experimentation, and a keen eye for potential. Look for cards that have unique or overlooked abilities, cards that synergize well with other cards, or cards that could be effective against popular strategies in the current meta. Online resources, forums, and communities can also be great places to discover underrated cards.

Are underrated cards only useful in certain formats?

No, underrated cards can be useful in any format, from Standard to Commander. The key is understanding the card’s potential and finding the right deck or strategy to maximize it. That being said, some underrated cards might shine more in certain formats due to the unique rules or dynamics of those formats.

How do I incorporate underrated cards into my deck?

Incorporating underrated cards into your deck involves a balance of popular and underrated cards, as well as a willingness to experiment with different deck builds. Remember, the true value of an underrated card often lies in how well it synergizes with the rest of your deck.

Can underrated cards become popular?

Absolutely! The popularity of cards in Magic: The Gathering can shift over time as the meta changes, new cards are introduced, and players discover new strategies. An underrated card that’s discovered to have a powerful effect or synergy can quickly rise in popularity.

Remember, the world of Magic: The Gathering is vast and ever-changing. Don’t be afraid to explore, experiment, and challenge the status quo. You never know when you might discover the next hidden gem. Happy gaming!

Leave a Reply

Discover more from MTGA Central

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading