Skip to content

What Is Goldfishing In MTG?

What Is Goldfishing In MTG

Introduction to Goldfishing in MTG

Key Takeaways: What Is Goldfishing In MTG

  • Goldfishing is essential for understanding and refining MTG decks.
  • It helps simulate games and test strategies against imaginary opponents.
  • Goldfishing aids in identifying deck strengths and weaknesses.
  • It is valuable for both beginners and experienced players.
  • Useful in adapting to the evolving MTG meta.
  • Enhances strategic thinking and decision-making skills.
  • Goldfishing practices vary across different MTG formats.
  • It contributes to personal growth and development in MTG.

Understanding the Basics

Introduction to Goldfishing in MTG

Hey there, fellow Magic: The Gathering enthusiasts! Today, I’m excited to dive into a topic that’s often overlooked but incredibly valuable for honing our skills in this fantastic game. We’re talking about What Is Goldfishing In MTG. For those new to the concept, goldfishing is a practice method where you play a game of Magic against an imaginary opponent, or as I like to say, against a ‘goldfish’.

This method is especially useful for testing new decks and strategies. When I first started playing MTG in the late ’90s, I spent countless hours goldfishing, which helped me understand my decks inside out. It’s a solo exercise where you simulate playing against an opponent, focusing solely on your own plays and deck’s performance.

Goldfishing allows you to evaluate how well your deck performs under different scenarios. You can track how quickly your deck can win, identify its strengths, and pinpoint areas that need improvement. It’s like having a practice session where the focus is entirely on your gameplay.

Origins of the Term “Goldfishing”

The term “goldfishing” has an interesting origin. Picture a goldfish in a bowl – it’s not going to provide much interaction or resistance, right? Similarly, when you’re goldfishing in MTG, your imaginary opponent is like that goldfish, offering minimal to no interaction. This term has stuck around in the MTG community for years, and it perfectly encapsulates the essence of this practice method.

Back in the day, I remember a friend introduced me to the concept, and it was a game-changer for me. We joked about how our imaginary goldfish opponent was the most patient and non-judgmental adversary we could ever face. But, in all seriousness, it allowed us to test our decks without the pressure of a real game.

How Goldfishing Helps

Let’s break down how goldfishing can benefit you as an MTG player:

  1. Deck Testing: By playing against an imaginary opponent, you can see how your deck operates in a vacuum. It’s a great way to test the mechanics and consistency of your deck.
  2. Strategy Improvement: Goldfishing helps in fine-tuning your strategies. You get to see which cards work well together and which don’t, helping you make necessary adjustments.
  3. Identifying Weaknesses: It also allows you to identify the weaknesses in your deck. Maybe you’re too vulnerable to certain types of cards or strategies, which you can only discover through consistent solo play.
  4. Enhancing Understanding: Lastly, goldfishing helps you better understand the fundamentals of the game. As you repeatedly play your deck, you become more familiar with its nuances and how to make the most of your cards.

In conclusion, What Is Goldfishing In MTG is an essential practice for any serious MTG player. It’s a fantastic way to test, refine, and understand your deck better. So next time you have a new deck or strategy, remember to give goldfishing a try – it might just be the key to your next big win in the world of Magic: The Gathering!

Why Goldfishing Matters in MTG

Why Goldfishing Matters in MTG

Improving Strategic Play

Goldfishing is more than just playing cards by yourself; it’s a strategic exercise that can significantly enhance your skills in Magic: The Gathering. When I first began goldfishing, I realized it was an invaluable method for sharpening my strategic thinking. By simulating games against an invisible opponent, I could focus on the strategic aspects of my deck without the unpredictability of an actual opponent.

Understanding Your Deck’s Dynamics

One key benefit of goldfishing is gaining a deep understanding of your deck’s dynamics. You get to see how your cards interact with each other in a controlled environment. This is crucial for identifying the most effective combinations and sequences in your deck. Through repeated practice, you become adept at recognizing the best play for any given situation.

Speed and Efficiency

Goldfishing also teaches you to play quickly and efficiently. In competitive MTG, time is a critical factor. Practicing your turns during goldfishing helps in making swift and accurate decisions during real matches. This skill is especially important in tournament settings where time management can be the difference between a win and a loss.

Enhancing Deck Testing

Goldfishing serves as an excellent tool for testing new deck ideas. Before introducing a deck in a competitive environment, it’s essential to understand how it performs solo. This method allows you to test various aspects of your deck in a focused setting.

Consistency Testing

The primary aspect you want to test through goldfishing is your deck’s consistency. You need to know how often your deck can execute its game plan effectively. By playing multiple games solo, you can gauge the consistency of your deck’s performance, which is a critical factor in competitive play.

Weakness Identification

Another crucial aspect is identifying potential weaknesses. While goldfishing, you might notice certain patterns, like struggling against imaginary control or aggro scenarios. This insight allows you to tweak your deck and prepare for these challenges in real games.


Goldfishing also helps in understanding the adaptability of your deck. How well does your deck respond to different situations? Can it handle various threats or disruptions? These questions are best answered through solo play, where you can simulate different scenarios and observe how your deck copes.

Goldfishing in MTG isn’t just about playing cards by yourself; it’s a comprehensive strategy tool. It allows players to understand their decks more deeply, improve their strategic play, and prepare for a wide range of scenarios. For anyone serious about their MTG game, goldfishing is an essential practice to embrace.

Step-by-Step Guide to Goldfishing

Step-by-Step Guide to Goldfishing

Setting Up for Solo Play

Goldfishing in Magic: The Gathering requires a bit of setup to make the practice as effective as possible. As a seasoned MTG player, I’ve found that a good setup is key to a productive goldfishing session. Here’s how I do it:

  1. Choose Your Deck: First, select the deck you want to test. It could be a new deck you’re building or an existing one you want to refine.
  2. Create Your Play Area: Find a comfortable and quiet space to play. Lay out your deck, life counter, and any tokens you might need.
  3. Simulate an Opponent: Though you won’t have a real opponent, imagine different scenarios that your imaginary opponent might present. This will help you test your deck’s response to various situations.
  4. Keep Track: Have a notepad and pen handy to jot down important observations. This could include how your deck performs under different conditions, card interactions, and areas for improvement.

Analyzing Your Deck’s Performance

Once you’re set up, it’s time to analyze your deck’s performance through goldfishing. This involves playing through several games by yourself, focusing on how your deck operates. Here’s what to look for:

  1. Speed and Consistency: How quickly does your deck get going? Are there consistent patterns in how it performs?
  2. Key Interactions: Pay attention to how well your cards interact with each other. Are there any combos or synergies that stand out?
  3. Weak Points: Identify any weaknesses in your deck. Are there certain types of cards or strategies that your deck struggles with?
  4. Adjustments: Based on your observations, make necessary adjustments to your deck. This might mean swapping out certain cards, tweaking your strategy, or testing different card combinations.

Goldfishing is a fantastic way to get to know your deck inside and out. It’s a practice I’ve relied on for years, and it’s been instrumental in my success as an MTG player. By following these steps, you too can harness the power of goldfishing to improve your game.

Goldfishing in Different Formats

Goldfishing in Different Formats

Goldfishing in Standard

Goldfishing in the Standard format of MTG offers a unique experience due to the ever-changing nature of the card pool. In Standard, the available cards are limited to the most recent sets, which means the strategies and deck compositions are constantly evolving.

Adapting to Meta Changes

In Standard, goldfishing helps you adapt to the frequent meta shifts. By practicing solo, you can quickly test new cards and strategies against the hypothetical popular decks in the meta. This practice is crucial for staying competitive in Standard, where understanding the current meta is key to success.

Testing Deck Resilience

Another aspect of goldfishing in Standard is testing your deck’s resilience against various archetypes. Since Standard often has a diverse range of powerful decks, it’s important to ensure your deck can handle different threats and strategies.

Goldfishing in Commander

Commander, known for its social and casual play style, also benefits greatly from goldfishing. In this format, decks are built around a single legendary creature, the commander, and typically contain 100 unique cards.

Understanding Your Commander

Goldfishing in Commander helps you understand how your deck interacts with your chosen commander. It’s a great way to test out how your deck functions without the commander, as well as how it performs when the commander is in play.

Exploring Interactions

Commander decks often have intricate interactions and combos due to the singleton nature of the format. Goldfishing allows you to explore these interactions in depth, helping you discover new and powerful synergies within your deck.

Goldfishing in different MTG formats like Standard and Commander offers distinct experiences and benefits. Whether it’s adapting to the evolving meta of Standard or exploring the unique interactions in Commander, goldfishing is an invaluable tool for players looking to improve their understanding and performance in these formats.

Advanced Techniques in Goldfishing

Advanced Techniques in Goldfishing

Identifying Key Combos and Synergies

When you’ve been playing Magic: The Gathering as long as I have, you learn that goldfishing is not just about playing your deck; it’s about deeply understanding it. Advanced goldfishing takes this concept to the next level, focusing on identifying and exploiting key combinations and synergies within your deck.

Finding the Winning Combo

Every deck has its gems, those card combinations that can turn the tide of a game. In advanced goldfishing, you’re not just playing cards; you’re actively searching for these powerful combos. It’s like a puzzle, where you’re putting pieces together in different ways to see what works best.

Synergy Over Solo Power

In MTG, synergy can often trump individual card power. Advanced goldfishing helps you see how cards enhance each other’s strengths, creating a cohesive and formidable deck. It’s about seeing the bigger picture and how each card contributes to your overall strategy.

Fine-Tuning Your Deck

Goldfishing also involves a constant process of fine-tuning your deck. This isn’t just about swapping out a few cards; it’s about making small, strategic adjustments that significantly impact your deck’s performance.

Adjusting to Meta Changes

The MTG meta is always evolving, and so should your deck. Advanced goldfishing allows you to test how well your deck adapts to new meta trends. It’s a proactive approach to ensure your deck remains competitive.

Balancing the Deck

Finding the right balance in your deck is crucial. This includes having the right mix of lands, creatures, spells, and other card types. Advanced goldfishing helps you find that balance, ensuring your deck performs consistently.

Goldfishing in MTG isn’t just a beginner’s tool; it’s a practice that evolves with you as a player. As you gain experience, your approach to goldfishing becomes more sophisticated, focusing on identifying key combos, synergies, and making fine adjustments. It’s a journey of continuous learning and improvement, and it’s what makes Magic: The Gathering an endlessly fascinating game.

Goldfishing in MTG Arena

Goldfishing in MTG Arena

Differences from Physical Play

Goldfishing in Magic: The Gathering Arena (MTGA) brings a different flavor to this practice. As someone who has experienced both physical and digital forms of MTG, I can tell you that MTGA adds a unique dimension to goldfishing. The digital platform changes the way you interact with your deck and the game.

Digital Interface

The most noticeable difference is the digital interface of MTGA. The platform automates many aspects of the game, like shuffling and damage calculations. This means you can focus more on strategy rather than the mechanics of gameplay.

Accessibility of Cards

In MTGA, you have access to a wide array of cards just a few clicks away. This makes experimenting with different deck builds in goldfishing much easier compared to the physical version, where you might not own all the cards you want to test.

Utilizing Arena’s Tools for Goldfishing

MTGA offers tools and features that can enhance your goldfishing experience. These tools provide insights that can be hard to replicate in physical play.

Deck Tracking

One of the best features for goldfishing in MTGA is deck tracking. The platform keeps a detailed record of your deck’s performance, allowing you to analyze your play more effectively. This data is invaluable for refining your deck and strategy.

Simulating Opponents

While you still don’t have a real opponent in goldfishing, MTGA can simulate various scenarios and opponent strategies. This helps in preparing for a wide range of situations you might face in actual play.

Goldfishing in MTG Arena offers a unique and valuable experience for players. The digital environment provides tools and features that can greatly assist in refining your deck and strategies. Whether you’re a seasoned MTG player or new to the digital platform, goldfishing in MTGA is an excellent way to enhance your game.

Common Misconceptions About Goldfishing

Common Misconceptions About Goldfishing

Clearing Up Myths

Goldfishing in Magic: The Gathering is often misunderstood, even by seasoned players. Over the years, I’ve heard numerous myths about this practice. It’s time to set the record straight and dispel some common misconceptions.

Misconception 1: It’s Only for Beginners

One common myth is that goldfishing is only useful for beginners. This couldn’t be further from the truth. Goldfishing is a valuable tool for players at all skill levels. It helps in understanding your deck’s mechanics, identifying strengths and weaknesses, and refining strategies, which are essential aspects of gameplay for both beginners and veterans.

Misconception 2: It Doesn’t Simulate Real Games

Another misconception is that goldfishing doesn’t accurately simulate real games because there’s no opponent. While it’s true that you’re not facing a live opponent, goldfishing allows you to focus on your deck’s performance without external influences. This helps in creating a solid foundation for your strategy, which is crucial in real-game scenarios.

Realistic Expectations from Goldfishing

It’s important to have realistic expectations about what goldfishing can do for you as a player.

Expectation 1: Understanding Your Deck

Goldfishing helps you understand the inner workings of your deck. It’s an opportunity to see how your deck operates in a controlled environment, allowing you to make adjustments and improvements.

Expectation 2: Strategy Development

Through goldfishing, you can develop and refine your strategies. This practice helps you identify which strategies work well and which need tweaking. It’s about learning the optimal ways to play your deck.

Goldfishing is an invaluable part of playing Magic: The Gathering. It’s not just for beginners, and it does more than just help you understand your deck. Goldfishing is about developing a deeper understanding of the game, refining your strategies, and becoming a better player. Dispelling these common misconceptions allows players to fully embrace and benefit from this practice.


What is the main purpose of goldfishing in MTG?

Goldfishing in Magic: The Gathering primarily serves as a tool for players to test and refine their decks in a solo play environment. It helps in understanding how a deck functions in different scenarios, identifying strengths and weaknesses, and improving overall gameplay strategies.

Can goldfishing help in competitive play?

Absolutely! Goldfishing is a valuable practice for competitive MTG players. It allows you to familiarize yourself with your deck, refine your strategies, and prepare for a variety of in-game situations. Regular goldfishing can significantly improve your performance in competitive settings.

How often should I goldfish my deck?

The frequency of goldfishing your deck can vary based on your goals and the level of competition you’re preparing for. As a general rule, I recommend goldfishing any new deck extensively before using it in competitive play and periodically goldfishing your main decks to stay sharp and adapt to any meta changes. Regular goldfishing sessions can provide continuous insights and improvements to your gameplay.

Summarizing the Benefits of Goldfishing

Goldfishing in Magic: The Gathering is more than a mere practice tool; it’s a pathway to deeper understanding and mastery of the game. Throughout my journey in MTG, goldfishing has been a constant companion, helping me refine my decks and sharpen my strategies. Let’s reflect on how this practice contributes significantly to a player’s development.

Understanding Your Deck

First and foremost, goldfishing helps you understand your deck’s mechanics, strengths, and weaknesses. This understanding is crucial for any player aiming to perform well in both casual and competitive scenes. Through goldfishing, you get to see how your deck operates in different scenarios, which is invaluable for making necessary adjustments.

Strategy Development

Goldfishing also aids in developing and refining your gameplay strategies. By playing against an imaginary opponent, you learn to anticipate various in-game situations, making you a more adaptable and strategic player. This practice sharpens your decision-making skills, a critical aspect of competitive play.

Meta Adaptation

In the ever-evolving world of MTG, adapting to the meta is key. Goldfishing allows you to test your deck against hypothetical meta scenarios, ensuring that your strategies remain relevant and effective. This adaptability is what sets apart great players from good ones.

Personal Growth

Lastly, goldfishing contributes to your personal growth as a player. It encourages patience, strategic thinking, and a deeper appreciation for the intricacies of MTG. It’s a practice that not only enhances your skills but also fosters a more profound connection with the game.

In conclusion, goldfishing in MTG is an essential practice for anyone serious about the game. It’s a journey of learning, adaptation, and growth that every player should embrace. Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned pro, the benefits of goldfishing are undeniable and vital for your development in the world of Magic: The Gathering.

Related Reading: Goldfishing in MTG

Magic: The Gathering is a game of endless depth and strategy, and there’s always more to learn. To further enhance your understanding and skill in MTG, it’s beneficial to dive into additional resources. Here, I’ll share some recommended readings that have helped me and many others in our MTG journey.

Goldfishing – MTG Wiki – Fandom
Goldfishing in Magic: The Gathering is a unique practice where players simulate a game without an opponent. This method is particularly useful for testing the efficiency and flow of a deck, allowing players to assess how well their deck performs in a vacuum. It’s an excellent way to understand the mechanics and potential of your deck, especially in terms of drawing and playing cards in sequence.

Best EDH deck to goldfish with? – MTG Salvation Forums
Discussing the best EDH decks for goldfishing, this forum thread on MTG Salvation highlights Yisan, the Wanderer Bard as a top choice. Goldfishing with Yisan offers a blend of competitive gameplay and accessibility, even for those on a budget. The thread provides insights into the deck’s strengths and how it fares in a goldfishing scenario, making it a valuable resource for players looking to optimize their solo play experience.

A Deck without Tutors – MTGNexus
This intriguing discussion on MTGNexus explores the concept of building a Magic: The Gathering deck without the use of tutors. The focus is on enhancing the goldfishing experience by relying on draw mechanics instead of tutors, offering a fresh perspective on deck building. It’s a thought-provoking read for players interested in experimenting with different strategies in their goldfishing sessions.

Goldfishing your deck better. A few tips – MTG Amino
MTG Amino presents a comprehensive guide on how to goldfish your deck more effectively. The article offers practical tips and strategies for Magic: The Gathering players, focusing on improving the goldfishing process. Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced player, these insights can help refine your approach to deck testing and enhance your understanding of your deck’s capabilities.

Goldfishing control decks? – MTG Forum – TappedOut
This forum post on TappedOut delves into the nuances of goldfishing with control decks in Magic: The Gathering. It discusses specific techniques, such as Sensei’s Divining Top manipulation in Miracles, offering valuable advice for players looking to master control decks in a goldfishing context. The post is a must-read for those interested in honing their skills with control strategies during solo play sessions.

Discover more from MTGA Central

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading