Skip to content

MTG Most Notable Fan Theories

MTG Most Notable Fan Theories


Magic: The Gathering (MTG) is not just a card game; it’s a universe filled with intricate lore, captivating stories, and enigmatic characters. Over the years, this rich tapestry of tales has given rise to numerous fan theories, each more intriguing than the last. From the true purpose of Ravnica’s Guildpact to the mysterious origins of the MTG planes, fans have delved deep into the game’s lore to uncover hidden truths and speculate on the unknown. In this post, we’ll explore some of the most notable fan theories that have captured the imagination of MTG enthusiasts worldwide.

Key Takeaways: Notable Fan Theories

  • The Guildpact in Ravnica aims to maintain balance among the ten guilds.
  • The origins of the MTG planes remain a mystery, with various theories suggesting their creation by powerful entities.
  • Avacyn’s fall in Shadows Over Innistrad has sparked numerous fan theories, including the involvement of the Helvault and Nahiri’s vengeance.
  • The Izzet League’s cryptic experiments and symbols are a source of fascination and speculation.
  • Liliana Vess’s pact with demons and the secrets of the Veil remain enigmatic.
  • The Lost City of Amonkhet has theories ranging from its destruction to its existence in a parallel dimension.
  • MTG’s rich lore has given rise to countless fan theories, showcasing the depth of the game’s universe.
  • The MTG community’s passion for the game’s lore is evident in their endless discussions and speculations.

The True Purpose of the Guildpact: Deciphering the Hidden Agendas of Ravnica’s Guilds

Fan Theories

The Guildpact, the binding agreement that governs the ten guilds of Ravnica, has long been shrouded in mystery. While it is generally understood that its purpose is to maintain balance and prevent all-out war, there are whispers among the citizens of Ravnica that there may be more to it than meets the eye. Is the Guildpact simply a tool for cooperation and governance, or does it serve a deeper, more sinister purpose? Some theorists believe that each guild has its own hidden agenda, and the Guildpact subtly manipulates their actions to fulfill an unknown objective.

One popular theory suggests that the Guildpact was created not to maintain peace, but to perpetuate conflict and competition among the guilds. This idea stems from the seemingly unending power struggles and feuds that plague Ravnica. Proponents of this theory argue that by pitting the guilds against each other, the true purpose of the Guildpact is revealed: to maintain a delicate balance of power, ensuring that no single guild becomes too dominant. This theory raises intriguing questions about the nature of the Guildpact and its true intentions. Will we ever unravel the hidden agendas of the guilds, or will the true purpose of the Guildpact continue to elude us? Only time will tell.

The Mysterious Origins of the Magic: The Gathering Planes

Magic: The Gathering, beloved by millions of players worldwide, encompasses countless planes, each with its own unique characteristics and lore. These planes are more than just settings for the game; they are intricately woven worlds, each with its rich history and origins. But have you ever wondered how these planes came to be? The answer lies in the enigmatic origins of the Magic: The Gathering planes.

The origins of these planes remain a mystery, shrouded in legends, tales, and rumors. Some believe that they were created by ancient beings of immense power, while others speculate that they are the remnants of shattered worlds. Regardless of their true origins, one thing is certain: these planes exist as a canvas for players to explore, imagine, and unleash their creativity. From the ferocious battles on the fiery plane of Dominaria to the intricate court intrigues of the plane of Ravnica, each plane offers a unique experience and a rich tapestry of stories waiting to be discovered.

Avacyn’s Fall: Investigating the Shadows Over Innistrad Fan Theories

The release of Shadows Over Innistrad, the horror-themed expansion set of Magic: The Gathering, left players with a barrage of questions and theories surrounding the fall of Avacyn, the plane’s beloved guardian angel. One popular theory suggests that the Helvault, the prison in which demons and other malevolent creatures were sealed away, somehow played a role in her downfall. Fans speculate that Avacyn’s imprisonment within the Helvault weakened her position, allowing the horrors of Innistrad to take advantage of her vulnerability. Others believe that Avacyn’s fall was orchestrated by Nicol Bolas, the powerful elder dragon planeswalker known for his manipulation and sinister machinations. These theories point to hidden motives behind Avacyn’s sudden decline, leaving players eager to uncover the truth behind her demise.

In addition to the helvault theory, another intriguing fan speculation suggests that Avacyn’s fall was a direct result of Nahiri’s plan for vengeance. As one of the three planeswalkers involved in locking the Eldrazi titans away on Zendikar, Nahiri’s rage and grief over the destruction caused by these powerful beings are well-documented. It is believed that she may have sensed Avacyn’s power and its connection to the angels who imprisoned the Eldrazi, leading her to plot against the guardian angel.

According to this theory, Nahiri could have taken advantage of Avacyn’s weakened state and used her own lithomancy abilities to directly or indirectly bring about Avacyn’s catastrophic demise. The intricacies of Nahiri’s plan and the motivations behind it are still shrouded in mystery, fueling the endless discussions and debates among Magic players worldwide.

The Hidden Code of the Izzet League: Unraveling the Guild’s Cryptic Experiments

The Hidden Code of the Izzet League: Unraveling the Guild's Cryptic Experiments

The Izzet League, a guild known for its eccentricity and love for scientific experiments, has always been a mystery to outsiders. Their cryptic experiments and puzzling codes have left many scratching their heads in confusion. It is no wonder that countless scholars and adventurers have dedicated their lives to unraveling the guild’s hidden code.

One of the most intriguing aspects of the Izzet League is their use of cryptic symbols and arcane formulas in their experiments. These symbols, often etched onto scrolls and laboratory equipment, are believed to hold the key to unlocking the guild’s secrets. Some scholars hypothesize that the symbols correspond to specific elements or concepts, while others believe they represent the guild’s philosophy and ambitions. Regardless, deciphering the hidden code of the Izzet League remains a daunting task that continues to captivate the minds of researchers worldwide.

The Enigma of Liliana Vess: Her Pact with Demons and the Veil’s Secrets

Liliana Vess, the enigmatic planeswalker, has long been a subject of intrigue for Magic: The Gathering enthusiasts. Her dark allure and entanglement with demons have fueled countless theories and speculations. Liliana’s notorious pact with demons, made in desperation to save her brother’s life, forever altered her destiny. This haunting bargain granted her incredible power, but at a great cost. The price she paid was her soul, forever chained to the demon planeswalker known as Nicol Bolas. With each passing set, players eagerly delve deeper into the mysteries surrounding Liliana’s past and the secrets hidden beneath the enigmatic Veil.

The Veil, a veil of shadows and secrets, has shrouded Liliana’s past in darkness. It is through this Veil that she has made her pact with the demonic forces of the Multiverse. The true nature of this pact remains a mystery, leaving players to wonder what Liliana’s ultimate fate will be. Will she find a way to break free from the clutches of her demonic masters, or will she succumb to their control and become a pawn in their grand schemes? The answers lie within the hidden codes and cryptic experiments of the Izzet League, as they race against time to unravel the secrets of Liliana’s past and secure their future.

The Lost City of Amonkhet: Examining the Theories Behind the Plane

The Lost City of Amonkhet has long been a subject of fascination for Magic: The Gathering players, with its ancient ruins and enigmatic past. Many theories have arisen regarding its origins and purpose, each one more intriguing than the last. One popular theory suggests that Amonkhet was once a bustling metropolis, teeming with life and prosperity. However, some cataclysmic event brought about its downfall, leaving behind only the remnants of its former glory.

Others believe that Amonkhet was designed as a grand experiment, a plane created to test the boundaries of its inhabitants’ strength and resilience. Whatever the truth may be, one thing is certain – the mysteries of the Lost City continue to captivate the minds of players and storytellers alike.

Another theory posits that the Lost City of Amonkhet was never truly lost at all. Instead, it is believed that the city exists in a parallel dimension, hidden from the eyes of ordinary mortals. This hidden realm is said to be populated by powerful beings, overseeing the trials and tribulations of Amonkhet’s residents. Some even claim that these overseers are none other than the planeswalkers themselves, watching with a mix of fascination and trepidation as mortals struggle to survive in their carefully constructed realm.

Whether these theories hold any truth remains to be seen, but one thing is for certain – the Lost City of Amonkhet continues to be a source of wonder and speculation for Magic: The Gathering enthusiasts.

Based on the search results, here are the working pages related to “Notable Fan Theories”:


The world of Magic: The Gathering is vast and ever-evolving, with each new set bringing fresh stories, characters, and mysteries. While some fan theories may eventually be confirmed or debunked by official lore, others will remain in the realm of speculation, fueling discussions and debates for years to come. Regardless of their validity, these theories showcase the depth of the MTG universe and the passion of its fans. As the game continues to grow and evolve, one thing is certain: the community’s thirst for knowledge and understanding of its beloved universe will never wane.

Related Reading: Notable Fan Theories

11 wild theories that completely change the way you look at famous movies
Louis Chilton takes a look at some of the craziest bits of cinematic speculation out there that could well be true. The article delves into fan theories about movies like Pixar films, Star Wars, Quentin Tarantino’s movies, and more.

32 Bizarre Fan Theories That Actually Make Sense
This article from Thought Catalog explores various fan theories related to popular movies and TV shows such as The Wizard of Oz, The Office, The Matrix, and more.

10 Creepy Fan Theories That Will Change The Way You View These Movies
Screen Rant presents ten intriguing fan theories about movies like Ferris Bueller’s Day Off, Titanic, Aladdin, and others that offer a different perspective on the stories.

17 Movie Fan Theories That Are So Darn Good, People Wish They Were Actually True
Buzzfeed lists 17 fan theories related to movies such as Harry Potter, Titanic, and the Marvel universe that fans wish were true.


What is the Guildpact in Ravnica and what is its true purpose?

The Guildpact is a magical contract that governs the ten guilds of Ravnica. Its true purpose is to maintain a balance of power and prevent all-out war between the guilds.

How did the Magic: The Gathering planes come into existence?

The origins of the planes are shrouded in mystery. Some theories suggest they were created by powerful entities, while others propose they have always existed as separate realms of existence.

What are the fan theories about Avacyn’s fall in Shadows Over Innistrad?

Some fan theories suggest that Avacyn’s fall was orchestrated by a hidden force seeking to disrupt the balance of power on Innistrad. Others believe it was a natural consequence of her role as a protector.

What experiments has the Izzet League been conducting?

The Izzet League is known for its cryptic and often dangerous experiments. Some speculate that they are trying to harness the power of the plane itself, while others believe they are searching for new sources of energy.

What secrets does Liliana Vess hold about her pact with demons and the Veil?

Liliana Vess made a pact with four powerful demons in exchange for eternal youth and power. The secrets she holds about the Veil are unknown, but some believe it is connected to her ability to travel between planes.

What theories exist about the lost city of Amonkhet?

There are several theories about the lost city of Amonkhet. Some believe it was destroyed by a cataclysmic event, while others think it was hidden away by powerful magic. Some even speculate that it may still exist in a different plane altogether.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from MTGA Central

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading